Rethinking New Year’s Resolutions: A Mental Health–Informed Approach

As a licensed professional counselor, I often hear mixed reactions when the topic of New Year’s resolutions comes up. For some, January represents hope, motivation, and a fresh start. For others, it brings pressure, shame, or a familiar sense of failure tied to resolutions that didn’t stick. From a mental health perspective, it’s important to pause and ask not just what we are resolving to change, but how and why we approach change in the first place.

The idea of a “new year, new you” can be both inspiring and problematic. While it’s natural to reflect at the turn of the year, this mindset can unintentionally suggest that who you are right now is somehow not enough. In counseling, we emphasize that growth does not require self-rejection. Meaningful change tends to emerge from self- compassion, curiosity, and realistic goal-setting—not harsh self-criticism.

One reason New Year’s resolutions often fail is that they are frequently based on

extremes. Common resolutions such as “I’m going to completely change my diet,” “I’ll never procrastinate again,” or “I’m going to be a totally different person this year” set us up for disappointment. The nervous system, habits, and emotional patterns don’t shift overnight. When goals are too rigid or perfectionistic, even small setbacks can feel like total failure, leading many people to give up entirely by February.

From a counseling lens, it can be helpful to shift from resolutions to intentions.

Resolutions tend to focus on outcomes, while intentions focus on process and values.

For example, instead of resolving to “exercise every day,” an intention might be “I want to build a kinder relationship with my body” or “I want to move in ways that support my mental health.” This reframing allows flexibility and acknowledges that life includes stress, illness, and unexpected challenges.

Another important factor is understanding the emotional role a behavior plays. Many habits we want to change, overworking, emotional eating, avoidance, scrolling, or substance use, serve a purpose, even if they cause problems. They may help regulate anxiety, numb pain, or provide temporary relief. When resolutions ignore this emotional function, they often fail. Sustainable change requires asking, What need is this behavior meeting, and how else might I meet it? Therapy can be especially helpful in exploring these deeper patterns.

New Year’s resolutions can also activate comparison. Social media is filled with

messages about productivity, fitness, finances, and “leveling up.” For individuals

struggling with depression, trauma, chronic stress, or emotional numbness, these

messages can feel alienating or overwhelming. Progress in mental health is rarely linear and often invisible. Getting out of bed, setting boundaries, or attending therapy consistently may be far more meaningful goals than those that look impressive from the outside.

A mental health–informed approach to the new year includes setting goals that are specific, compassionate, and adaptable. Instead of asking, “What should I change about myself?” consider asking:

• What do I want more or less of in my life?

• What helps me feel regulated, connected, or grounded?

• What is one small, realistic step I can take in that direction?

Small changes matter. Research and clinical experience consistently show that

incremental shifts—five minutes of mindfulness, one honest conversation, one therapy appointment, one evening of rest—are more likely to stick than dramatic overhauls.

These small steps build trust with yourself, which is foundational for long-term change.

It’s also worth remembering that January is not a magical deadline. Growth is not

confined to the calendar. If the new year feels heavy rather than hopeful, that’s okay.

Some seasons are for action, others for rest, reflection, or healing. There is no rule that says you must be motivated on January 1st to be worthy of growth later.

As a counselor, I encourage people to view the new year as an invitation rather than a demand.

An invitation to check in with yourself honestly. An invitation to notice what

you’ve survived, what you’ve learned, and what you might need next. Whether that means setting clear goals, focusing on emotional healing, or simply choosing to be gentler with yourself, all of these are valid paths forward.

Ultimately, the most meaningful “resolution” may not be about becoming someone new, but about becoming more fully yourself—at a pace your mind and body can truly support. If you would like to discuss this topic deeper, please feel free to reach out to me.

Let's Chat